When Our Beliefs About Leadership Hold Us Back
This article explores some of the less visible obstacles to stepping into senior leadership: the assumptions we carry about the kind of person a leader needs to be.
[6 min read]We tend to think about leadership development as adding something: more confidence, more strategic thinking, more executive presence, more influence.
But sometimes the work requires the opposite. Rather than adding more, we need to strip away the layers of assumptions, expectations and beliefs that have accumulated over time – and that might be getting in our way.
To question what we’ve absorbed about what leadership looks like, who gets to lead and whether that person can still be us.
I was reminded of this while supporting a client whose story illustrates this particularly well.
What if what holds you back isn’t what you lack, but what you’ve come to believe leadership requires of you?
When leadership doesn’t feel like you
This spring, I was working with an exceptionally talented expert who very quickly struck me as a natural leader. Not only because of what he valued, but because of the way he treated people.
And yet he found himself in a familiar dilemma:
The situation was calling for him to take more initiative and lead through a complicated relationship dynamic. He knew it mattered deeply to him – important enough to seek support – but at the same time, he was close to walking away from it altogether.
It felt like we’d reached a threshold: the point where something deeper than a practical obstacle was asking to be looked at. As we explored what was underneath his hesitation, we found a powerful conflict.
He wanted to lead. But he didn’t want to become the kind of person he believed a leader had to be.
His experience of authority, particularly from other men, had been dominated by people who were imperious, controlling and self-important.
And he knew very clearly: that wasn’t who he was. Nor did he want it to be.
So, over time, he had developed a way of keeping leadership at a safe distance. He would take responsibility for his work, contribute, support others – but consistently withdraw from taking responsibility for others.
Not because he lacked the capability. Because, somewhere underneath, he believed that taking the lead meant becoming someone he fundamentally disagreed with.
It was as if the meaning of leadership had become a shipwreck sitting at the bottom of the sea: still there, still shaping what was possible, even though he was no longer consciously thinking about it.
And yet his natural way of leading was very different. He was a harmonising force. He brought calm and balance into difficult human situations. He could create conditions in which people worked together rather than against each other.
But this way of leading didn’t fit his internal definition of what leadership was allowed to look like.
So the question wasn’t: “How do we make him more of a leader?”
It was:
“What if leadership doesn’t have to mean what you have learned it means?”
We started testing the belief. We looked for situations in which he already felt able to lead in a way that was natural to him. And there were many.
In those contexts, he could see himself differently: not as someone who might one day become a leader, but as someone who already knew how to lead – in a way that was aligned with who he was and what he valued.
That experience became important. It gave him something more useful than an intellectual reframe: evidence of himself as a leader.
From there, he could begin returning to the situations that had previously triggered his resistance – including those involving the destructive, ego-driven form of leadership he feared.
He wasn’t learning to become someone else. Instead, he could choose how he wanted to show up, rather than organising his behaviour around avoiding who he was afraid he might have to become.
We often underestimate how much our ideas about authority, influence and what a leader should be can shape the way we approach our own leadership.
The Leadership Mindset That Holds You Back
Sometimes there is a conflict between who we are and who we believe we need to become in order to lead.
It can sound something like:
“Being a leader means being dominant.”
“And that’s simply not who I am.”
Or:
“Senior leaders need to be tough and highly assertive.”
“If that’s what leadership requires, perhaps I’m not made for it.”
The problem is that beliefs like these don’t stay in our heads – they become scripts for action.
They influence what we notice, what we avoid, where we step forward, where we hold back – and ultimately the experience other people have of us as leaders.
This matters particularly when you’re preparing for a more senior role. At this level, technical expertise and a track record of delivery are no longer enough on their own. You are increasingly expected to take ownership beyond your immediate responsibilities, navigate complex relationships and influence decisions that affect others.
If your internal definition of leadership makes some of these behaviours uncomfortable or undesirable, you may find yourself holding back precisely where you need to demonstrate your readiness.
Preparing for Senior Leadership: Three Questions to Ask Yourself
So how do you begin to unravel the assumptions that may be holding you back? Start by reflecting on what senior leadership means to you – and what you believe it will require of you.
Think about the senior leadership role you’re moving towards – or imagining yourself moving towards.
1. What is it about that role that attracts you most?
This can tell you something about what you genuinely care about, what you value and what you want to create with greater influence.
2. What is it about that role that you imagine would challenge you most?
This can reveal what you associate with leadership – and where your idea of what a senior leader “needs to be” might be at odds with who you are.
Then go one layer deeper:
3. What is the biggest threat this aspect of leadership poses to me personally?
That question is particularly interesting because the resistance often makes more sense once you understand what you are protecting yourself from.
What emerges from these questions can tell you something important about your readiness for senior leadership – which assumptions might be influencing the way you approach your next step.
Recognising these patterns is a starting point. The next step is noticing how they show up in your decisions, relationships and behaviour.
From there, you can begin to challenge those assumptions – not just intellectually, but by choosing to respond differently in practice.
You don’t have to become the kind of leader you’ve known. You can redefine what leadership looks like through the way you lead.
Get an Outside Perspective on Your Leadership Readiness
Gaining this perspective isn’t always easy to do on your own.
Partly because we don’t get much practice at it. But also because we sometimes need another person to act as a mirror – not simply to give us feedback, but to help us notice what we’re reluctant to see, question assumptions we’ve taken for granted, and explore possibilities we haven’t considered.
Explore your leadership readiness through tailored one-to-one coaching:
Your experience and capabilities are important, but they don’t always tell the whole story of your readiness for senior leadership.
In a Diagnostic Session we’ll explore the less visible factors influencing your leadership effectiveness, recognise potential barriers and gain clarity on the shifts that could help you move forward.
About the author
Miriam Kochan is an Integrative Psychologist, ICF-certified Coach and specialist in Leadership Psychology and Executive Readiness. She works with experienced managers preparing for senior leadership roles, helping them understand and navigate the psychological, behavioural and relational shifts required at the next level.
Drawing on 900+ hours of coaching and 9+ years of international experience in career and leadership development, Miriam brings together psychology, coaching and business experience to support meaningful transitions into senior roles.
